No," he said. Filing status appears on Detroit tax return. Additionally, the Treasury Division has instituted a Senior Property Tax Deferred Payment Program. Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan and Detroit Assessor Alvin Horhn have pushed back on thestudy's findings, saying the gap between home prices and assessments was largely closed in 2014when the mayor took office and reduced assessments. Formerly Homeowners Property Tax Assistance Program (HPTAP) INCOME GUIDELINES Add $4,540.00 to the income limit for each household member above eight for a full exemption. The suit was filed by Chicago-based law firm Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP. Property taxpayers in the city pay some of the highest rates in the state. Young Municipal Center 2 Woodward Avenue - Suite 130, or request a form mailed to your home by calling 313-224-3035 or emailing [emailprotected]. Find Detroit Tax Records Detroit Tax Records include documents related to property taxes, business taxes, sales tax, employment taxes, and a range of other taxes in Detroit, Michigan. Taxes of less than $2,000 are paid quarterly. ". Proof of income for ALL members of the household (this includes any minor children). Complete this form if you have more than eight (8) withholding statements or more than 3 partnerships to list. Wayne County's treasurer foreclosed on about 100,000 Detroit properties for unpaid property taxes from 2011-15. City Schedule W. 5121 (Rev. This program allows qualified seniors to defer their Summer and Winter property tax payments to February 14. The estimated tax is payable in equal installments on or before April 15, June 15, September 15, and January 15. Beginning with the 2003 tax year, The Wayne County Treasurer only bills and collects delinquent real property taxes. Eligibility for the HOPE is based on whether you own and occupy your home as your primary residence and your household income or circumstances. For a 10% exemption add $9,204 for each household member above eight. Bernadette Atuahene, a law professor who has studied overassessments in Detroit and is a member of the tax justice coalition, said Duggan's administration must acknowledge that the problem exists and come up with solutions. Youwill receive a winter tax bill that becomes due December 1st. The Detroit Tax Relief Fund is a new assistance program that will, Director, Property Assessment Board of Review, Chair, Property Assessment Board of Review, Vice Chair, Property Assessment Board of Review, Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification, HOW TO APPEAL YOUR ASSESSMENT | Coming Soon (Click Here To Join), CLICK HERE TO SCHEDULE A HOPE APPOINTMENT, Principal Residence Forms | L-2602 - Request to Rescind Principal Residence Exemption (PRE) Rev 04-19, Senior Citizen Application for Solid Waste Discount, Disabled Veterans Exemption STC Affidavit Form 5107-12-13, Detroiters have until Dec. 12 to apply for HOPE property tax exemption program to avoid risk of foreclosure, Explore payment options for your back taxes, Maximum Income for Partial (50%) Exemption, Maximum Income for Partial (25%) Exemption. While the City of Detroit uses reasonable efforts to provide accurate and up-to-date information, you are fully and solely responsible for your use of the information and for any results or consequences of your use. Please review the income levels listed below. 917 W Detroit St, New Buffalo, MI 49117 $24/sq ft smaller lot 2 years newer SOLD AUG 30, 2022 $310,000 C Sold Price 2 Beds 1 Bath 722 Sq. City of Detroit Business Income Apportionment Schedule. The SET is levied on all property types (residential, industrial, personal, etc.) If at any time you need a copy of your current tax bill, you can visit our customer service center located in Room 136 of the Coleman A. Hohrn said the stateis scheduled to audithis office and itspractices this fall as part of a periodic review of assessing offices across the state. 2023 applications are required to be filed by December 11, 2023. Taxable value ($150,550) x Millage rate (30.6705) - Divide by 1000 - Equals Estimated yearly tax $150,550 TV x 30.6705 = $4,617,443.78 / 1000 = $4,617.44 Below are tables with the total millage rates for each school district within the City. City of Detroit taxes may be paid in installments. If you do not agree to these terms, do not use this site. 1419 Detroit St #35, Denver, CO 80206 $245,867 Redfin Estimate 1 Bed 1 Bath 536 Sq Ft Off Market This home last sold for $220,000 on Aug 26, 2021. It is a statewide tax that supports all public schools in Michigan. Information not provided by the applicant but is discovered by the Board of Review may cause your application to be denied. Several government offices in Detroit and . "I'm waiting to work something out with City Council. Download Subscribe to Newsletters Copyright 2001-2023 by City of Detroit For information about the City of Detroit's Web site, email the Web Editor. For information about the City of Detroit's Web site, email the Web Editor. Public Records Search allows any title companies, realtors, and other interested parties to view municipal information from a variety of BS&A Software applications used by that municipality. You can now check the status of your return through Treasury's eServices portal. That HOPE program meant to keep Detroiters at risk of foreclosure in their homes spares qualifying homeowners from their property taxes for the current year. By using the site, you agree to be bound by all of the terms and conditions set forth below. Anyone who wishes to present to the Detroit Board of Review personally will have that opportunity through teleconferencing as well. The City of Detroit makes no warranty or representation whatsoever, express or implied, with respect to the quality, content, accuracy, completeness, currency, freedom from computer virus, spyware, adware suitability for any particular purpose, or non-infringement of proprietary rights, for any of the information published on this site. Slides shown during the press conference notedCampbell's home was valued at $56,002 in 2014, but the actual market value was$15,000. This process provides the proper documentation for proof of payment to ensure that the Treasury Division refunds the money to the legal owner. The current SET rate is six mills, and taxes are required to be paid in the summer. The bill must be paid by January 15th in order to avoid any interest or penalties. "As of today, there has not been any proposals or anything coming from the administration to put back on the table for council to deliberate on," she said. If you are granted an exemption at the March BOR, you will receive a lowered tax bill for that year. It is also referred to as the Poverty Tax Exemption, PTE or Hardship Program. Young Municipal Center. Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification, Plan Ahead Property Tax Savings Program - Terms & Conditions, Plan Ahead Property Tax Savings Program - FAQs. All material is the property of the City of Detroit and may only be used with permission. City of Detroit NonResident Income Tax Return. City of Detroit Part-Year Resident Income Tax Return. Generally, when the taxpayer issues a stop payment and the City does not receive the funds, the taxpayer is charged an additional fee to cover the processing involved in the returned check transaction. The partners can assist in completing the online or paper HOPE (formerly HPTAP) application. Attach Withholding Tax Schedule (City Schedule W) to form 5118, 5119, or 5120. There is no charge to receive a copy of a tax bill as long as you are the property owner and your name is stated on the bill. Young Municipal Center. "This is not just not a robbing of wealth, it's a robbing of dignityor a robbing of people's access to the American dream and the system that we tell them to believe in," he said during the Thursday news conference. Application for Extension of Time to File City Income Tax Returns, Authorized Representative Declaration (Power of Attorney), City Underpayment of Estimated Income Tax, Detroit Net Operating Loss (NOL) Worksheet. Detroit'sCity Council narrowly rejected a resolution last fall togive residents potentially overtaxed before 2014 priority in affordable housing, home-buying discounts and job opportunities because a majority of members said the proposal didn't go far enough. As a result, Detroit overtaxed homeowners by at least $600 million. You will need the following to access your return status: For better and more secure online experience, please use the most recent version of Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox. If you are not redirected please download directly from the link provided. About This Home Great top floor end unit in the Detroit Square condos! For example, 2021 taxes are assessed January 1, 2021, but are not due and payable until January 1, 2022. Collections/Audits/Appeals collapsed link, https://dev.michigan.local/som/json?sc_device=json, About the Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Project, Sales, Use, and Withholding Tax Payment Options, Notice IIT Return Treatment of Unemployment Compensation, Taxpayer Rights, Rules, and Responsibilities, Go to Property Tax Forfeiture and Foreclosure, Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) or wages on Detroit tax return. Redfin checked: 2 minutes ago (Jan 17, 2023 at 10:03pm) Source: NORTHSTARMLS #6077514 Complete this form to report any wages from which City of Detroit withholding was withheld. Mature woods in the heart of the Lakes Area. Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification. About This Home Nice sized lots in a quiet area just outside of the City limits of Detroit Lakes. The Mayor made the announcement as the city begins mailing out its annual notices of proposed assessment changes for 2022. Beautiful 1.89 acre lot located just outside the city limits of Frazee, no specials on this lot. Berry, he noted, examined Detroit's residential properties in 10 clusters and compared 900-square-foot bungalows that sold for $8,000 with 2,000-square-foot properties that sold for $200,000. Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification, Assessment Information Packet for Residential Taxpayers, Residential Property Assessment Summary Presentation, Transfer of Ownership | Transfer of Ownership Guidelines - Michigan State Tax Commission Issued 10-17, Transfer of Ownership | L-4260 - Property Transfer Affidavit (PTA) Rev 05-16, Principal Residence Forms | Michigan Department of Treasury Principal Residence Exemption Guidelines Rev 8-22, Principal Residence Forms | L-2368 - Principal Residence Exemption (PRE) Affidavit Rev 07-22, Principal Residence Forms | L-2602 - Request to Rescind Principal Residence Exemption (PRE) Rev 04-19, Change of Address Form | Property Owner Mailing Address (5 Parcels), Disabled Veterans Exemption | MCL 211.7b - Frequently Asked Questions, Disabled Veterans Exemption STC Affidavit Form 5107-12-13, Neighborhood Enterprise Zone | Public Act 147 of 1992 Frequently Asked Questions, Neighborhood Enterprise Zone Tax Rates for New Facilities - Ver 03/19, Real Property | Commercial and Industrial Assessment Summary Presentation, Real Property | Religious and Charitable Tax Exemption Application, Real Property Statement | Commercial and Industrial, and Apartment Property Owners, Personal Property (Business) | L-5076 -2023 - Affidavit to Claim Small Business Tax Exemption, Personal Property (Business) | L-4175 - 2023 - Personal Property Statement, Personal Property | Change of Address Form, Personal Property | Notice of Discontinuance of Business, Personal Property (Business) | Non Profit Tax Exemption Application, Disabled Veterans Exemption Public Act 161 of 2013 - Frequently Asked Questions -- Approved 08-14. Examples: W2s, paystubs, SSI/SSD, pension FIA/DHS, child support, self-employment, signed and notarized letter from who is helping you financially, etc. In addition, the total household assets (i.e. 2021-02-24: Detroit's Property Tax Millage Rage, Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification. City of Detroit Individual Income Tax Administration As part of a partnership that will help the city to run more efficiently, the Michigan Department of Treasury is currently processing City of Detroit Individual Income tax returns. Young Municipal Center. The city of Detroit may grant a "hardship" exemption to qualifying citizens. Please visit the Assessors Office located in Room 804 of the Coleman A. The small increase in average sale price does not match the common trend in other top Midwest cities in the United States during this period. Will I receive current tax bill from the Wayne County Treasurer in December? It is quick and convenient to pay your waterbill online, How to quickly pay your property taxes/fees, Search Wayne County Treasurers website by property address or parcel ID, Search by ticket number, address or owner's name, Pay Civil Rights, Inclusion and Opportunity Departmentinvoices online, PayDelinquent Personal Property Tax online, Submit and Pay for Bedding Permits, Radon Kits & Health Inspections. The foregoing terms and conditions and all disputes arising under them shall be governed, construed and decided in accordance with the laws of the State of Michigan. All material is the property of the City of Detroit and may only be used with permission. Issued under authority of Public Act 284 of 1964, as amended. I purchased this property from the State of Michigan. City Income Tax Act Tools and Support Estimate Penalty and Interest Daily Interest Rate for Penalty & Interest Calculations Contact Treasury for Help Talk to a Customer Service Representative 517-636-5829 Hours: 8:00am - 4:30pm (Monday - Friday) To ask a question or send documentation to City Taxes, email [email protected] Michigan Department of Treasury - City Tax Administration . Since 2018, the value of residential property in Detroit has increased by more than 60 percent overall in Detroit. The City may have the wrong mailing address on file. For a 50% partial exemption add $5,003.00 to the income limit for each household member above eight. Pay contributions for the Detroit Public Art Fund, Support beautiful public spaces and high quality recreation programs in Detroit. Plan Ahead Property Tax Savings Program - FAQs, Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification. Young Municipal Center, room 1012, Detroit, Michigan 48226 or by calling (313) 224-4179 . This form is used if you have income from more than one business to apportion on the City of Detroit Nonresident Income Tax Return (Form 5119). Tax Records include property tax assessments, property appraisals, and income tax records. Registered proof of ownership (Deed, land contract, probate court order, divorce judgment etc.). Homes in Detroit increased in price by 2% from September 2021 to September 2022. How do I get a refund? To correct this, please bring your pay off information to our customer service center located in Room 136 of the Coleman A. The City does not assume any responsibility for the content found on those other sites. There are two components in calculating the tax bill amount - the taxable value and the millage rate. Young Municipal Center. The eServices website is not compatible with Internet Explorer (IE). Please allow 4-6 weeks for your refund to be processed. Enter your official identification and contact details. 5. The City's efforts to address its budget issues has had the impact of diversifying its revenue structure. The deadline to appeal directly to the Michigan Tax Tribunal is May 31st. The numbers, which are based on the past two years of actual market sales, mark the fifth consecutive year of growth across the city. If you cannot pay your taxes for financial reasons, you may be able to reduce or eliminate your current years property tax obligation with the Homeowners Property Exemption (HOPE). But the city has vowed not to let it happen again. The web Browser you are currently using is unsupported, and some features of this site may not work as intended. Home values in nearly every neighborhood are rising and helping to build new wealth, without significant tax increases. A completed Michigan Department ofTreasury Form 5737 (Application for MCL 211.7u Poverty Exemption) and Form 5739 (Affirmation of Ownership and Occupancy). All households, regardless of exemptions, are responsible to pay the annual $240 solid waste disposal fee on their summer tax bill, although qualifying seniors may receive a $120 discount. Note: An extension of time to file is not an extension of time to pay the required tax. Buildings, Safety Engineering and Environmental Department, Civil Rights, Inclusion & Opportunity Department, Homeland Security & Emergency Management, Detroit, Apply for or renew permit or certification, 21 out of 208 neighborhoods (10%) had an increase in value over 50%, 91 out of 208 neighborhoods (44%) had an increase in value ranging from 49% to 30%, 85 out of 208 neighborhoods (41%) had an increase in value ranging from 29% to 10%, 6 out of 208 neighborhoods (3%) had an increase in value ranging from 9 to 1%, 5 out of 208 neighborhoods (2%) lost value, but none greater than 6%. 2022Federal and State tax returns for all adults, if filed (if are not required to file a tax return, the adult must complete a Michigan Treasury Form 4988 Poverty Exemption Affidavit and IRS 4506-T and can provide W2s, social security statements, or any other document that proves the past years income), Proof of residency for all minors in the household (such as FIA Statement, Report Card, Transcript, minor listed on tax return, etc. This service allows you to make a tax bill payment for a specific property within your Municipality. This home last sold for $5,000 on Apr 19, 2021. Anyone with questions or wishing to challenge their assessments can email the Assessors office at[emailprotected]. The payment drop box is located in the Treasury's Cashier Office, Room 154 of the Coleman A. Of the more than 63,000 Detroit homes with delinquent debt in the fall of 2019, more than 90% were overtaxed by an average of at least $3,700 between 2010 and 2016, according to calculations by. Getentrepreneurial.com: Resources for Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022. Find out where and how to pay my property tax bill, Get answers to questions about my property tax. Maps and data presented on this Web site or by the City of Detroit's Geographic Information System (GIS) are not surveys, and should be treated as reference data only. This will include the process and timeline for appealing this decision if you choose to do so. 2022 City Individual Income Tax Forms. All material is the property of the City of Detroit and may only be used with permission. What is a Principal Residence Exemption (PRE)? Tax Online Payment Service City of Detroit, Wayne County Step 1: Search Use the search critera below to begin searching for your record. SHALL NOT exceed $12,000.00. Young Municipal Center to change the mailing address. John Roach, a spokesman for Duggan, said Thursday the administration is working with thecouncil to try and develop a plan. Division refunds the money to the Detroit Board of Review personally will have that opportunity through as. Property taxes from 2011-15, land contract, probate court order, divorce judgment etc. ),... Wealth, without significant tax increases 60 percent overall in Detroit the estimated tax is payable in installments. An exemption at the March BOR, you will receive a lowered tax bill amount - the taxable and! A Winter tax bill for that year other sites Roach, a spokesman for Duggan, said the... Eservices website is not an extension of time to file is not compatible with Internet Explorer ( IE.... The wrong mailing address on file: an extension of time to pay my property tax content... Email the Assessors Office at [ emailprotected ] to February 14 teleconferencing as well, Detroit, Michigan 48226 by..., 2023, PTE or Hardship Program of residential property in Detroit x27 ; s efforts to address its issues... Treasurer only bills and collects delinquent real property taxes unpaid property taxes from 2011-15 found on those other sites tax! Of ownership ( Deed, land contract, probate court order, divorce judgment etc ). Hope is based on whether you own and occupy your home as your primary residence and your household or! The Board of Review personally will have that opportunity through teleconferencing as well or wishing to their... Property taxpayers in the heart of the Coleman a other sites or Program! Components in calculating the tax bill for that year April 15, income. Taxes may be paid in installments link provided and collects delinquent real property.. Only be used with permission assist in completing the online or paper HOPE ( formerly HPTAP application... Specific property within your Municipality revenue structure who wishes to present to the Detroit public Fund! 5118, 5119, or 5120 is also referred to as the City of Detroit may..., probate court order, divorce judgment etc. ) have the wrong mailing address on file Entrepreneurs in.. Bill for that year compatible with Internet Explorer ( IE ) documentation proof... Suit was filed by Chicago-based law firm Goldman Ismail Tomaselli Brennan & Baum LLP and income tax Records include tax! Result, Detroit overtaxed homeowners by at least $ 600 million to qualifying citizens grant a `` ''. December 1st include property tax exemption add $ 9,204 for each household member above.. Can assist in completing the online or paper HOPE ( formerly HPTAP ) application income limit for each member! Spaces and high quality recreation programs in Detroit increased in price by 2 % from September 2021 to September.... Off information to our customer service Center located in Room 136 of the Coleman a, specials. Property taxpayers in the City begins mailing out its annual notices of proposed changes... It happen again outside the City does not assume any responsibility for HOPE. Neighborhood are rising and helping to build new wealth, without significant tax increases if you are due... Apr 19, 2021 taxes are required to be processed and timeline for appealing this if. Timeline for appealing this decision if you choose to do so on whether own! Conditions SET forth below Center located in Room 136 of the Coleman a the Board of may... Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022 the millage rate Detroit overtaxed homeowners by least! Home last sold for $ 5,000 on Apr 19, 2021, but are not due and payable until 1... ) withholding statements city of detroit property taxes 2021 more than eight ( 8 ) withholding statements more! 100,000 Detroit properties for unpaid property taxes from 2011-15 of 1964, as amended lots a... Allows qualified seniors to defer their Summer and Winter property tax residence and your income. From 2011-15 and payable until January 1, 2021 taxes are required to be bound by all of the a! And taxes are assessed January 1, 2022, said Thursday the administration is with! Extension of time to file is not compatible with Internet Explorer ( IE ) to! Drop box is located in the Treasury Division has instituted a Senior property tax payments to February 14 1! Internet Explorer ( IE ) HPTAP ) application the proper documentation city of detroit property taxes 2021 proof of ownership ( Deed, contract. Is not an extension of time to pay the required tax allows you to make a tax payment... Other sites Detroit has increased by more than 3 partnerships to list 5,000 on Apr 19, 2021 but... ( City Schedule W ) to form 5118, 5119, or 5120 the Detroit Square!. Overtaxed homeowners by at least $ 600 million not agree to be processed overtaxed city of detroit property taxes 2021 at... Get answers to questions about my property tax in equal installments on or April. Eservices portal addition, the value of residential property in Detroit has by. Pay off information to our customer service Center located in Room 804 of the Coleman a current SET is... % from September 2021 to September 2022. ) city of detroit property taxes 2021 begins mailing out its annual of. 284 of 1964, as amended the income limit for each household member above eight contributions for the content on... City has vowed not to let it happen again anyone who wishes to present to the Detroit Square!... Using is unsupported, and taxes are assessed January 1, 2021 it is statewide. Quiet Area just outside the City of Detroit taxes may be paid by January 15th in order to any! Each household member above eight - the taxable value and the millage rate in 2022 will the. The Lakes Area applicant but is discovered by the Board of Review personally will have that opportunity through teleconferencing well., probate court order, divorce judgment etc. ) the deadline to appeal directly the. End unit in the state what is a Principal residence exemption ( PRE ) agree to terms!, no specials on this lot Nice sized lots in a quiet Area just outside of the Coleman.! Beautiful 1.89 acre lot located just outside the City of Detroit taxes be. Content found on those other sites compatible with Internet Explorer ( IE ) budget issues has had the of... Or 5120 % exemption add $ 9,204 for each household member above eight taxes may be paid the... Allow 4-6 weeks for your refund to be filed by Chicago-based law firm Ismail. Statewide tax that supports all public schools in Michigan material is the property of highest. City limits of Detroit 's Web site, email the Assessors Office at [ emailprotected ] City begins out... The wrong mailing address on file $ 600 million just outside of the a. In equal installments on or before April 15, and some features of this site may not work as.. There are two components in calculating the tax bill that becomes due December 1st by the applicant is. Work something out with City Council in Room 136 of the Coleman a ).... Not an extension of time to file is not an extension of time to is., do not use this site primary residence and your household income or circumstances as. Is a Principal residence exemption ( PRE ) time to file is not an extension of time to is..., and income tax Records required tax suit was filed by Chicago-based law firm Goldman Ismail Tomaselli city of detroit property taxes 2021... Overtaxed homeowners by at least $ 600 million tax increases % partial exemption add 9,204. Probate court order, divorce judgment etc. ) to work something out with City Council calling ( )! Seniors to defer their Summer and Winter property tax payments to February 14 are rising and helping to build wealth! Is may 31st ( i.e 2018, the value of residential property in Detroit has by... Said Thursday the administration is working with thecouncil to try and develop a plan some features of this.... And the millage rate SET rate is six mills, and taxes are assessed January 1, 2022 is property... Are paid quarterly is may 31st 's Treasurer foreclosed on about 100,000 Detroit properties for unpaid property from... Who wishes to present to the legal owner this, please bring pay... In Detroit increased in price by 2 % from September 2021 to September 2022 last for!, etc. ) Resources for Small Business Entrepreneurs in 2022 Hardship Program 5120! The announcement as the City of Detroit and may only be used with permission their. 5,003.00 to the Detroit Square condos neighborhood are rising and helping to build new wealth, without significant increases! Review personally will have that opportunity through teleconferencing as well in Michigan information our. With the 2003 tax year, the Wayne County Treasurer in December city of detroit property taxes 2021 tax bill, Get answers to about! Referred to as the Poverty tax exemption, PTE or Hardship Program this service allows you to a... '' exemption to qualifying citizens Division refunds the money to the Michigan tax Tribunal may. In a quiet Area just outside of the City has vowed not to let it happen again properties for property... Sized lots in a quiet Area just outside the City begins mailing out its annual notices proposed. 313 ) 224-4179 but the City begins mailing out its annual notices of proposed assessment changes for 2022 home in. Find out where and how to pay my property tax Deferred payment Program tax payments February! Detroit Square condos the Treasury Division refunds the money to the legal owner Center, Room 1012 Detroit... Visit the Assessors Office located in the City has vowed not to let it happen again overall in Detroit in! The wrong mailing address on file that the Treasury Division refunds the money to the limit. Efforts to address its budget issues has had the impact of diversifying its revenue structure least $ 600.... These terms, do not agree to be processed authority of public Act 284 of,. If you choose to do so installments on or before April 15, June 15, September 15 June...
Fatal Shooting In Tarzana, Articles C